Sacking an Attorney General when you have a small majority is a risky business

When you have a majority in the parliament of two and the opinion polls show you are in electoral trouble a Prime Minister is not in the mood to cause a by-election. Even less so when the vote would be in a state where your party has just been reduced to two members. 
And that is the nub of a great difficulty for Scott Morrison when all and sundry are telling him that he should sack Christian Porter as his Attorney General.
What if Mr Porter responds to being told he is being dismissed by submitting his resignation not just from the Cabinet but from the House of Representatives as well?
And lest you think that's an unlikely prospect let me take you back to April when Jim Killen was Minister for Defence and I was carrying cases of beer to the cars of customers at my bottle shop. In those days Jim had a staff of two - a shorthand/typist/secretary and a private secretary on secondment from his department. There were none of those myriad of advisers that these days clutter up ministerial offices to proffer an opinion about what their boss should or should not do.

So when Jim, who had picked up the scuttlebutt that the Prime Minister was unhappy with his peformance, was instructed to prepare for a meeting in the Prime Ministerial office later in the day he called and asked me to join him for a quick drink and a spot of advice. Now Jim and I having a quick drink or two was not unusual. We were mates in those days when Labor lads and Liberal ministers were still allowed to be friends (I got married in his house with Graham Freudenberg as the best man before hopping off to watch the Brisbane Cup.) 
Jim was mightily distressed. He loved being Defence Minister and dreaded the prospect of ending his career by returning to the backbench. What was my advice?
Politely, ever so politely, call the big fellow's bluff. Tell him you appreciated his right to choose his own ministry, express your sorrow, wish him all the best and tell him you would immediately retire as the member for Moreton. See if he was courageous enough to risk a by-election he would surely lose.
The ruse worked. Fraser insisted on replacing him as Defence Minister but created a new Cabinet portfolio of Vice-President of the Executive Council and Leader of the House. A knighthood followed.
I do not know Mr Porter but imagine he would be far from happy to be forced out of hs post as the first law officer. Can Scomo find him aother job he would accept?







Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is Scott Morrison getting ahead of Malcolm Turnbull in the GST debate?

Image
Michelle Grattan , University of Canberra Scott Morrison has become a true believer in the cause of raising the GST, determined to drive a major switch in the tax mix. The big question is whether Malcolm Turnbull will end up in the same place as his treasurer. Turnbull is keeping his options open. “Changes to the GST are certainly part of the tax debate and certainly being actively considered by the government,” he said on Friday. If Turnbull agrees with Morrison, all will be well and good between them. On the other hand if Turnbull eventually opts for caution and doesn’t walk down the GST road, or in the shorter term feels Morrison is getting ahead of the game, that would be awkward for the gung-ho minister, who would the need to manage his retreat. Morrison wants a high profile and he seeks the limelight. But that carries risks. There is always that salutary tale from Labor days. Paul Keating was passionate about introducing a broad-based consumption tax. Bob Hawke let ...
Read more

Grattan on Friday: Now Malcolm Turnbull is the sniper at the window

Image
Michelle Grattan , University of Canberra There’s a nice story about Arthur Fadden - the Country Party leader who became PM in the 1941 hung parliament amid conservative leadership turmoil - deciding not to move into the Lodge after a colleague told him he’d “scarcely have enough time to wear a track from the backdoor to the shithouse before you’ll be out”. The warning was prophetic: Fadden was dispatched in little over a month, replaced in a House of Representatives vote by Labor’s John Curtin. Scott Morrison, ensconced in Kirribilli, has already had a longer spell than Fadden, and his government appears safe in parliament, despite losing its majority. Regardless of these differences, Morrison’s likely trajectory seems as clear as that of “Artie” all those years ago. The widespread feeling that the Morrison government is doomed will only be reinforced by this week’s outbreak of hostilities between the former and current prime ministers. At one level, it’s hard to believe we’r...
Read more

Malcolm Turnbull's government has finally defied fiction

Image
Grattan on Friday: With the eligibility of the Nationals’ leadership under question, Malcolm Turnbull has had a nightmarish week. Mick Tsikas/AAP Michelle Grattan , University of Canberra In a week belonging more appropriately to Shaun Micallef comedy than parliamentary reality, it’s arguable Pauline Hanson’s burqa stunt wasn’t the most extraordinary thing that happened in Canberra. Hanson has extreme beliefs and therefore it mightn’t be so surprising – though it is appalling – that she’s willing to use the parliament as a stage for extremely bad behaviour. In donning the burqa purchased on eBay and entering the Senate chamber, she was as attention-seeking as the streaker who races naked across the football ground, though her motive was darker. Let’s call out her action, but not play into her cynical pursuit of mega publicity. Entirely beyond imagination was the week being bookended by the Nationals leader, Barnaby Joyce , and his deputy, senato...
Read more